Loading matchups...

Welcome to The Stats Lab

AFL Starter Squad to Beat — Round 23

AFL Starter Squad to Beat — Round 23

August 14, 2026

Round 23 has been played.

For this week's calls, see the AFL predictions hub with every upcoming game, updated with the team lists, or head to the AFL hub for all the latest analysis.

Defenders

Callum Wilkie (Saints v Tigers) · Avg: 112.8 · Pred: 119.5
The best defender matchup of the round. Richmond are the league’s easiest matchup for intercept + rebound-50 rate conceded (+5.6%, 1st) — exactly the profile that suits an intercepting key defender. The clean top-ranked draw explains the jump over season average.

Lachie Ash (Giants v Eagles) · Avg: 119.7 · Pred: 123.3
West Coast sit dead on the league average for intercept + rebound-50 rate conceded (+0.0%, 9th) — a genuinely neutral draw. Ash’s volume carries the pick rather than any matchup edge.

Lachie Whitfield (Giants v Eagles) · Avg: 119.2 · Pred: 121.6
Shares Ash’s neutral Eagles draw for intercept + rebound-50 rate conceded (+0.0%, 9th). Two Giants defenders backed on class in an even matchup.

John Noble (Suns v Lions) · Avg: 120.2 · Pred: 117.2
Brisbane are a mild positive for intercept + rebound-50 rate conceded (+0.9%, 7th) — nothing dramatic, but trending the right way for a rebounding half-back.

Archie Roberts (Bombers v Swans) · Avg: 118.9 · Pred: 109.3
Sydney are a mild negative for intercept + rebound-50 rate conceded (-0.7%, 10th) — close to neutral, no standout concern.

Josh Daicos (Magpies v Hawks) · Avg: 120.2 · Pred: 120.5
Hawthorn rank 15th for intercept + rebound-50 rate conceded (-2.3%) — a genuinely below-average draw. Daicos’s class and ball-use are doing the heavy lifting through a tougher-than-average matchup.

Darcy Wilmot (Lions v Suns) · Avg: 102.6 · Pred: 117.1
The toughest defender draw in the squad. Gold Coast rank 16th (-3.5%) for intercept + rebound-50 rate conceded — a genuinely hard matchup for a rebounding defender. Selected on the size of the jump over his own season average rather than the opponent doing him any favours.

Midfielders

Clayton Oliver (Giants v Eagles) · Avg: 113.3 · Pred: 121.6
The best midfielder matchup of the round, and it’s not close. West Coast are the league’s easiest matchup for clearance differential conceded (+10.4%, 1st) — exactly the terrain Oliver thrives in around the stoppages.

Nick Daicos (Magpies v Hawks) · Avg: 142.8 · Pred: 147.7
Hawthorn rank 4th (+4.3%) for clearance differential conceded — a genuine positive for a ball-magnet midfielder. The highest prediction in the squad, built on quality and a favourable draw together.

Lachie Neale (Lions v Suns) · Avg: 124.1 · Pred: 128.2
Gold Coast rank 6th (+2.8%) for clearances conceded — a modest positive, not the standout some might assume. Neale’s own class is carrying most of the weight here.

Will Ashcroft (Lions v Suns) · Avg: 124.8 · Pred: 130.8
Shares Neale’s Gold Coast draw for clearance differential conceded — the same modest +2.8% (6th) positive. Two Lions midfielders backed on quality in a decent but unspectacular matchup.

Isaac Heeney (Swans v Bombers) · Avg: 120.2 · Pred: 127.3
Essendon rank 8th (+1.6%) for clearances conceded — close to league average. Heeney’s forward-midfield hybrid role means he’s less reliant on clearance winnings anyway, which helps offset the modest matchup signal.

Bailey Smith (Cats v Kangaroos) · Avg: 139.4 · Pred: 138.1
North Melbourne rank 16th (-7.1%) for clearance differential conceded — a genuinely tough matchup. Smith’s class through the midfield is what’s carrying this pick, not the draw.

Jordan Dawson (Crows v Dockers) · Avg: 136.6 · Pred: 138.3
The toughest midfield draw in the squad. Fremantle are the league’s 2nd-hardest team to win clearances against (-7.5%, 17th) — a genuinely difficult matchup for any inside midfielder. Dawson’s sheer output keeps him in the squad regardless.

Rucks

Brodie Grundy (Swans v Bombers) · Avg: 113.1 · Pred: 122.6
Essendon are a mild negative for hitouts conceded (-1.7%, 14th) — not a great sign for a ruck reliant on hitout-to-advantage work, but Grundy’s all-round ground game means he’s never purely dependent on the tap.

Max Gawn (Demons v Power) · Avg: 122.5 · Pred: 126.8
The tougher ruck draw of the two. Port Adelaide rank 17th (-5.1%) for hitouts conceded — a genuinely hard matchup at the stoppages. Gawn’s status as the highest-averaging ruck in the pool is what keeps him in, not the opponent.

Forwards

Toby Greene (Giants v Eagles) · Avg: 102.6 · Pred: 110.9
The best forward matchup of the round. West Coast are the league’s 2nd-easiest team for forward-50 entries conceded (+24.1%) — a genuinely outstanding number for a small forward who thrives on repeat forward-half access. Greene also spends real time through the midfield, so some of his output won’t come purely from forward-half supply.

Bradley Hill (Saints v Tigers) · Avg: 112.9 · Pred: 120.2
Richmond rank 4th (+16.0%) for forward-50 entries conceded — a strong positive for a small forward working the space in front of goal. Worth noting Hill actually plays predominantly in defense these days, so this forward-50 matchup only tells part of the story.

Max Hall (Saints v Tigers) · Avg: 103.6 · Pred: 109.3
Shares Hill’s favourable Richmond draw (+16.0%, 4th) — good news for another Saints forward looking to capitalise on repeat entries. Hall also gets time through the midfield, adding a layer of output the forward-50 number alone doesn’t capture.

Izak Rankine (Crows v Dockers) · Avg: 108.7 · Pred: 109.8
Fremantle rank 6th (+5.0%) for forward-50 entries conceded — a mild positive, sitting a touch above league average. Rankine spends time in the midfield too, so his ceiling isn’t fully tied to Adelaide’s forward-half entries.

Kysaiah Pickett (Demons v Power) · Avg: 118.5 · Pred: 116.9
Port Adelaide rank 7th (+4.4%) for forward-50 entries conceded — close to Rankine’s number, a modest positive for a small forward working hard around the ground. Pickett also rotates through the midfield, another avenue for output beyond this matchup.

Zac Bailey (Lions v Suns) · Avg: 105.1 · Pred: 113.3
Gold Coast rank 12th (-4.8%) for forward-50 entries conceded — a below-average draw. Bailey’s pressure game and season form are carrying the pick through a tougher-than-ideal matchup, and his regular midfield minutes give him a way to offset a quiet forward-half matchup.

Harry Sheezel (Kangaroos v Cats) · Avg: 136.9 · Pred: 131.6
The toughest forward draw in the squad. Geelong rank 16th (-15.2%) for forward-50 entries conceded — a genuinely hard number. Sheezel’s the highest average in the squad regardless, and his half-forward running game — plus regular midfield time — generates its own supply independent of team entries.

The Stats Lab Starter Squad to Beat: AFL Round 23 team


The free weekly cheat sheet

JT's best NRL + AFL calls, in your inbox before lockout every week.

AFL
Round 23
GDS
Starter